Chapter 4 - Behind Closed Doors
When I returned to the Austin house at two that afternoon, Piper was still with my parents. I had refused to bring her back into a house that felt like a minefield.
The front door was unlocked. Inside, the house was stiflingly quiet.
Wes sat at the dining table, a stack of unopened mail in front of him. Gavin was slumped on the living room sofa, staring at his phone, while Brynn stood at the stove, waiting for a kettle to boil. Micah was nowhere to be seen—probably back in his room, drawing.
When the front door clicked shut behind me, all eyes shifted.
“Where’s Piper?” Wes asked immediately. His voice was defensive, laced with the nervous edge of a man anticipating an ambush.
“She’s in Georgetown with people who don't treat her like an intruder,” I said.
Brynn let out a short, mocking breath. “Right. Because she’s the victim.”
“Brynn, shut up,” Gavin muttered from the sofa. It was the first time I’d heard him push back against his sister. He didn't look at her; he was watching me, his jaw set.
I walked straight to the dining table and unzipped my leather tote bag. I pulled out a three-ring binder containing five months of printed bank statements, utility logs, and credit card summaries. I dropped it on the table directly between Wes and the mail. It landed with a dull, heavy thud.
“What is this?” Wes asked, not touching it.
“That’s the ledger,” I said loudly enough for Brynn and Gavin to hear. “Come here, Brynn. You too, Gavin.”
Brynn turned off the burner beneath the kettle. “I don't need to look at your spreadsheets.”
“Yes, you do,” I said, my voice dropping an octave, cold and level. “You stood in my kitchen yesterday and told a five-year-old girl that your father shouldn't have to spend his money on a child who isn't his. You looked her in the face while she was holding a paper crown and made her believe she stole from your brother. If you're old enough to humiliate a child, you're old enough to look at the numbers.”
Gavin stood up from the sofa. He walked over slowly, standing three feet from the table. Brynn hesitated, then crossed her arms and joined him, her chin tilted up in defiance.
“Page twelve,” I told them, pointing at the binder.
Neither of them moved, so I flipped the pages open myself.
“This is the joint household account. Your father and I each put twelve hundred dollars into it every month. That pays for the electric bill, the water, the internet, and groceries. On September eighteenth, four days before Micah’s birthday, twelve hundred dollars went in from me, and twelve hundred from your dad. On the same afternoon, nine hundred dollars was pulled back out and transferred directly into your father’s personal checking account.”
I looked at Wes. He had folded his hands together so tightly his knuckles were white.
“Tell them what the nine hundred was for, Wes.”
He stared straight ahead. “Mara, this is inappropriate.”
“Tell them!” I shouted.
The sound shocked the room. I had never raised my voice in that house—not once in eight months. Even Brynn flinched.
“He won't tell you,” I said, turning back to the teenagers. “So I will. Piper’s preschool tuition doesn't come from this account. I pay it from my personal account that Wes doesn't have access to. Piper’s birthday party—every single balloon, the cake from the bakery, the pizza yesterday—was paid for with a check my parents gave me. Your father didn't spend one single cent on Piper’s birthday.”
Brynn’s eyes darted to Wes. “Dad? You said she used the household card for the party supplies.”
Wes didn't look at her. “Brynn, go to your room.”
“No,” Gavin said suddenly.
His voice was deeper than his father’s, thick with an anger that had broken loose from its moorings. He stepped closer to the table, looking down at the binder.
“You said she bought an organic cake that cost eighty dollars,” Gavin said, his gaze fixed on Wes. “You said she spent three hundred dollars on customized favors. You told me that was why you couldn't replace my cleats for soccer.”
“Gavin—”
“You told me I had to tape my shoes because Mara needed organic strawberries for a preschooler!” Gavin’s voice rose, cracking in the middle. “I played three games with duct tape around my left toe because you said she was bleeding you dry!”
“I was trying to protect you!” Wes snapped, finally looking up, his face twisted. “You think you know how this works? Claire is taking me back to court! She hired an attorney in Bexar County to garnish my wages because the firm cut our bonuses in June! I had to retain an attorney! That nine hundred dollars went to a retainer so I wouldn't lose this house!”
The silence that followed was suffocating.
Brynn stared at him, her face completely pale. “You hired a lawyer... to fight Mom?”
“To protect what we have here!” Wes insisted, gesturing wildly around the open-concept living room. “If she takes forty percent of my net income, we can’t live in this school district! You’d have to change schools your senior year, Brynn! I did it for you!”
“You didn't do it for me,” Brynn whispered. Her arms dropped to her sides. All the defensive swagger she had worn like armor for eight months vanished, leaving only a terrified seventeen-year-old girl. “You told us Mara was selfish. You let us hate her. You let us break Piper’s heart yesterday.”
May you like
“Brynn—”
“You made us monsters,” she said, tears finally breaking over her lashes. “You made us act like monsters to a little girl.”
